ISSN : 0970 - 020X, ONLINE ISSN : 2231-5039
     FacebookTwitterLinkedinMendeley

Investigation on Synthesis and Applications of Novel Polymeric Composites for the Removal of Heavy Metal Ion

Rajeswari Balakrishnan1 and Santhi Radhakrishnan2*

1,2K.Ramakrishnan College of Engineering, Samayapuram, Tiruchirappalli – 621112, Tamil Nadu, India

2Department of Chemistry, Seethalakshmi Ramaswami College, Affiliated to Bharathidasan University, Tiruchirappalli – 620002, Tamil Nadu, India.

Corresponding Author Email: santhichemsrc@gmail.com

DOI : http://dx.doi.org/10.13005/ojc/360417

Article Publishing History
Article Received on : 07 July 2020
Article Accepted on : 08 Aug 2020
Article Published : 19 Aug 2020
Article Metrics
ABSTRACT:

Conducting polymers were synthesized by doping polyaniline chloride with Schiff bases such as (E)-2-((4s-chlorobenzylidene)amino) -3- (3a,7a-dihydro-1H-indol-3-yl)propanoic acid (TP4ClB) and (E)-3-(3a,7a-dihydro-1H-indol-3-yl)-2-((2-hydroxy-3,5-diiodobenzylidene)amino) propanoic acid (TPDISA). A chemical oxidation method using potassium persulphate as an oxidising agent was followed for the preparation of polymers. The prepared polymers were characterized by UV-Visible, FTIR and proton H1NMR spectroscopic techniques. The adsorption characteristics of Polymeric composites for the removal of mercuric ion was studied through batch process. Sorption isotherms were constructed using Langmuir, Freundlich, Dubinin Radush Kevich, Temkin and Redlich Peterson models. SEM micrograph, PXRD and EDX spectra were also recorded to confirm the metal ion adsorption on the surface of investigated composites.

KEYWORDS:

Adsorption; Polymeric Composite; Mercuric Chloride; Tryptophan; Schiffbases

Download this article as: 

Copy the following to cite this article:

Balakrishnan R, Radhakrishnan S. Investigation on Synthesis and Applications of Novel Polymeric Composites for the Removal of Heavy Metal Ion. Orient J Chem 2020;36(4).


Copy the following to cite this URL:

Balakrishnan R, Radhakrishnan S. Investigation on Synthesis and Applications of Novel Polymeric Composites for the Removal of Heavy Metal Ion. Orient J Chem 2020;36(4). Available from: https://bit.ly/3iVf5zG


Introduction

Environmental contamination due to minerals and heavy metals  is the major challenging problem in our country. The concentration of heavy metals due to industrial and agricultural waste materials have been increased to the levels of high risk.1-4 Among the  various metals like  lead, mercury, chromium ,arsenic, nickel, uranium, selenium, silver, cadmium, zinc and gold present in industrial waste water, discharge of Hg (II) ions cause severe environmental contamination as it is non-degradable and bio- accumulate in nature.5-8 Fertilizers industry, power generation plants, paper manufacturing, rubber processing and oil refineries are found to be the great sources for the emission of mercury into the universe. Health issues such as dialysis and problem in central  nervous system occur  due to  circulation of mercury in the blood and storage in brain, liver, spleen, kidney and bone. Hence it is right time to carryout the research on the removal of mercuric ion from the environment.3-5 Though the number of methods such as reverse osmosis, floatation , adsorption, coagulation, flocculation, electrodialysis, chemical precipitation, nanofiltration, ion exchange, ultrafiltration, chemical precipitation and nanofiltration have been practiced for discarding the heavy metals, adsorption is an economical and more suitable one as it is simple to perform, easy to operate at low budget  for the removal of toxic contaminants.  Hence an attempt has been made to synthesize a novel organic polymer by doping polyaniline chloride with the potential schiff bases. The synthesized organic polymers have been characterized by UV-Visible, FTIR and H1NMR spectroscopy. The adsorption characteristics of pani composite for the removal of mercuric ion was studied through batch process.9-11 Langmuir, Freundlich, Dubinin Radushkevich, Temkin and Redlich Peterson isotherms have been verified. Adsorption of the metal ion on the organic polymer has been confirmed by PXRD,SEM analysis and EDX spectra.

Experimental Methods

Materials and Methods

The reagents and solvents were used  as such( AR grade). Aniline (BDH) was distilled under reduced pressure before use. All the experiments were carried out using Double distilled water. Hydrochloric acid &  sodium hydroxide solutions  were used to study sorption behavior of the solutions at different pH.

Preparation of Schiff Bases

The Schiff bases (E)-2-((4s-chlorobenzylidene)amino) -3- (3a,7a-dihydro-1H-indol-3-yl) propanoic acid (TP4ClB) and (E)-3-(3a,7a-dihydro-1H-indol-3-yl)-2-((2-hydroxy-3,5-diiodobenzylidene)amino)propanoic acid (TPDISA) were prepared by the condensation of tryptophan(2.04g) with equivalent amount of  4-chlorobenzaldehyde 3,5-diiodosalicylaldehyde  respectively the reaction was performed in presence of an acid and refluxed for 4 hours. The solid product formed was filtered at the suction pump and washed with ethanol. Then it was dried over anhydrous CaCl2 in a vaccum desiccator and recrystallised with alcohol.

Preparation of Polyaniline Chloride

Aniline (0.1M) was dissolved in aqueous solution of hydrochloric acid (1M). The mixture was stirred using a magnetic stirrer and 50ml of potassium persulphate (0.1M) was added drop wise to the aniline-acid mixture for about two hours with continuous stirring at 303K. The contents were stirred further for 30 minutes to ensure complete polymerization. A dark green coloured PaniCl thus formed was filtered using a Whatmann No. 1 filter paper. The excess acid content and oligomers of aniline were removed by repeated washings with distilled water, ethanol, acetone and diethyl ether11. The green coloured polymer obtained was dried in an air oven for four hours till constant weight was reached.

The colour changes that appeared during the addition of potassium persulphate is given below. Straw yellow ®yellow ®brown ®green colour.

Preparation of Polymeric Composite

PaniCl (1g) and  schiffbase (TP4ClB, TPDISA) (1g) were mixed together and suspended in 15ml of diethyl ether and sonicated in an ultra sonic cleaning bath (NEY, 50 Khz) for 30 minutes. The slurry obtained was centrifuged and the supernatant liquid was removed. The resulting product was washed with ether and centrifuged. The dark green coloured mass obtained was dried in a vacuum desiccator to get a free flowing powder.

Spectral Analysis

UV-Visible spectra of the polymeric composites were recorded in DMSO using Lambda 35 Perkin Elmer UV- Visible spectrophotometer (200-1100nm). FTIR spectra were recorded as KBr pellets using a Perkin Elmer FTIR spectrometer in the range of 4000-400cm-1. H1NMR spectra were carried out DMSO on a Bruker 400 MHz Nuclear Magnetic Resonance spectrometer. The Powder X-ray diffraction pattern of mercuric chloride after adsorption was performed using  Bruker D8 X-ray diffractometer ,Germany at a scan rate of 1 step/second. The  sample was irradiated with CuKα radiation and studied  in the range 20-80º (2Ɵ) with a step size of 0.001º. The SEM and EDX spectra of pani matrix were studied using Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscope.

Sorption Experiments

Polymeric composites (2mg) were suspended in a solution of mercuric chloride (10 ml, 0.02M) and sonicated for half an hour  at room temperature and centrifuged.  Five ml of the supernatant liquid was pipetted out and titrated against KI solution by conductometric method11,13. The mercuric chloride concentration in the centrifugate was calculated from the   plot of  conductance Vs volume of KI. The sorption curves were constructed from the concentration of mercuric chloride  after adsorption (Ce). The initial concentrations (Co) were in the range of 0.01-0.05M.

Effect of Temperature

The adsorption of HgCl2 solutions on Polymeric composites were studied at 5°C intervals ranging from 303  – 318 K to understand the temperature effect. Polymeric composites (2 mg) and HgCl2 (10ml, 0.02M) were sonicated for 30 minutes, after which the concentration of mercuric chloride was determined.

Effect of Contact Time

A known amount (2mg) of adsorbent was sonicated with 10ml of 0.02M of HgCl2 solution at different equilibrium time (10-60minutes). The optimum time required for maximum adsorption of HgCl2 was found to be 30 minutes.

Effect of pH

The influence of pH on the adsorption capacity of polymeric composites were investigated in the pH range  1-13. The compounds (10mg) were suspended in 2.5 ml of conductivity water. HgCl2 (2.5ml, 0.05M) and   hydrochloric acid (10-1 to 10-6 M) were added and sonicated for 30 minutes to understand adsorption behaviour in low pH. Similarly, NaOH solutions (10-1 to 10-6M) were used for the study at  alkaline pH.

Results and Discussion

Novel organic pani composites polyanilinechloride-(E)-2-((4s-chlorobenzylidene)amino) -3- (3a,7a-dihydro-1H-indol-3-yl)propanoic acid (PTP4ClB) and polyanilinechloride-(E)-3-(3a,7a-dihydro-1H-indol-3-yl)-2-((2-hydroxy-3,5-diiodobenzylidene)amino)propanoic acid (PTPDISA) were  prepared, characterized by UV-Visible , FTIR and proton NMR  spectra and compared for their adsorption capacity.

UV-Visible Spectra

Electronic spectra of the composites exhibit two bands from 290 nm to 357 nm due to π- π* transitions in benzenoid rings and carbonyl present in carboxylic acid  group of tryptophan moiety while polyaniline chloride shows absorptions11  at 310 and 583 nm. This shift in λmax value to lower wavelength confirms the doping of schiff bases on polymer. A small shift observed in both the compounds confirms the adsorption of mercuric ion.

Table 1: Uv-Vmolecule isible spectral analysis of polymer composites

Name of the compound

Λmax (nm)

PTP4ClB

301, 329

PTP4ClB- HgCl2

299,329

PTPDISA

297,357

PTPDISA-HgCl2

298,363

PaniCl

310,583

PaniCl-HgCl2

260,602

FTIR Spectra

The presence of absorption bands in the range 3500-4000 cm-1 may be OH stretching frequency of -COOH  group of tryptophan of molecule in schiff base doped on pani chloride. Appearance of  bands at 1645 – 1656 cm-1 due to CH=N stretching vibrations of imines confirms the doping of  schiff base on polymer. The composites exhibit peaks between 2312-2358cm-1 due to  the presence of  iminium sites on pani matrix. The  vibrations around 1487-1514 cm-1 indicate the signature peaks of the pani back bone arising due to the stretching modes of the imino benzenoid rings. The broad peaks in the region 1000-1100cm-1 may be attributed to C-N stretching modes of primary amine. The bands around 940-990cm-1 are generally assigned to bending mode of  O-H bond. The bending vibrations of the pani back bone are observed around 600-690cm-1.  Both PTP4ClB and PTPDISA exhibit a band at about 3300-3400cm-1 due to N-H  stretching of amine present in schiff base. A peak at 597cm-1 due to C-Cl and 555 due to C-I further supports the presence of schiff base on the composite. The peaks at 1224 cm-1, 1261 cm-1 and 1004 cm-1 may be attributed to C -N stretching vibration.

Table 2: FTIR spectral analysis of polymeric composites

Name of the polymer

νN-H

ν O-H

ν C-H

ν C=N

νC-N

νC-H

δC-C

 

δC-H

 

PTP4ClB

3732

3400

2358

1654

1265 -1008

947,

642

597-553

PTP4ClB- HgCl2

3857-3739

2987-, 2318

1701-1645

1514

1049

977-921

559-513

PTPDISA

3859-3741

2380- 2312

1683-1649

1514- 1425

1004

947

599-555

PTPDISA-HgCl2

 

3377-3000

2353- 2154

1651

1363

1093

991

495-,459

PaniCl

3820-3713

3423

2985-  2358

1692- 1588

1487

1239

798

505

H1NMR Spectral Analysis of Polymeric Composites

Proton NMR spectral data (Fig.1a, b) further supports the doping of imines on pani back bone. Signals at 10.1&9.98 ppm for both the compounds envisage the presence of carboxylic acid proton in indole derivative of adsorbents. The signals around 8.0 and 8.3 are due to imine protons of PTP4ClB and PTPDISA. Appearance of multiplets in the range 6.6-7.7 for both the composites may be attributed to NH & CH  protons of the aromatic rings.

Fig. 1a. Proton NMR spectra of PTP4ClB

Figure 1a: Proton NMR spectra of PTP4ClB

Click here to View Figure

Figure1b: Proton NMR spectra of PTPDISA

Figure1b: Proton NMR spectra of PTPDISA

Click here to View Figure

Adsorption Studies of Mercuric Chloride on Pani Composites

Experiments on adsorption of mercuric ion by two new organic adsorbents were carried out by batch process. Concentration of mercuric ion in the filtrate after adsorption was measured conductometrically.

Effect of Variation of Mercuric Ion

Langmuir, Freundlich, Temkin,  Dubinin Radush- Kevich and Redlich- Peterson models are employed to evaluate the adsorption capacity and the surface properties of adsorbent related to adsorption.14-16

 Langmuir Isotherm

This model is used to calculate the amount of Hg2+ ions adsorbed (qm) by Polymeric composites. From the plot of 1/qe vs 1/Ce , it is  observed that the process obeys the Langmuir model. The Langmuir constants qm and KL determined from the slope and intercept of the plot are presented in Table 3.

1/qe = 1/ KL qm Ce +1 / qm  …………………(1)

In Langmuir equation(1) qm is the maximum monolayer adsorption capacity of the adsorbent (mg/g).

The essential characteristics of the Langmuir isotherm can be expressed by a dimensionless constant called the separation factor RL.

RL=1/1+KLC……………….…(2)

Where KL is Langmuir constant (mg g-1) and C0 is initial concentration of adsorbate (mg g-1).

 The RL values indicate that the adsorption process using the adsorbents under investigation is favourable (0<RL<1)17. qm value is greater  (0.884 mg/g) for PTP4ClB composite with  KL (11.06 L/g) and hence the Langmuir model is best fitted for PTP4ClB in comparison with PTPDISA.

Freundlich Isotherm

The Freundlich adsorption isotherm gives the sorption equilibrium for both monolayer and multilayer adsorption, and is evidenced by equation (3),

log qe= log kF + 1/n log Ce …………………………(3)

where n is related to the intensity of adsorption and kF denotes adsorption capacity. From the plot of log qe Vs log Ce the Freundlich isotherm constant kF (sorption capacity) and 1/n (intensity of sorption) are calculated17-21. The correlation coefficients  R2 are shown in Table 3. The higher value of kF  is found for PTPDISA (kF = 1.873) indicating multilayered formation.

Dubinin Radush-Kevich Isotherm

 The Linear form of DR isotherm is

ln qe = ln qD-Bε2 …………………. (4)

A plot of lnqe Vs ε2 is found to be a linear trace and the constants qD and B calculated from the slope and intercept are presented in Table 3. Dubinin Radush-kevich (DR) isotherm has been usually applied to know whether the adsorption of metal ion is physisorption or chemisorption. The isotherm constant B is relatively higher for PTP4ClB (2.198). From this model it is found that physical nature of adsorption is more suitable for both the composites.

Temkin Isotherm                                                                                                                              

This isotherm is used to understand the adsorbent –adsorbate  interactions. The linearity of Temkin isotherm is represented by equation (5)

qe= BT ln AT + BT ln Ce ……………………………..(5)

The Temkin isotherm equilibrium binding constant (AT) and the Temkin heat of adsorption (BT) are calculated using the slope and intercept of the plot qe Vs lnCe. Temkin heat of adsorption BT is found to be high for PTP4ClB. The higher values of binding constant is observed for PTP4ClB.

Redlich-Peterson Isotherm

RP isotherm can be applied for homogeneous or heterogeneous systems due to its versatility17-21. The mathematical relation of this isotherm is given by equation (6).

Ce/qe = 1/KRP + αRP/KRP Ceβ …………………. (6)

Where,  KRP , αRP and β are constants. A plot of Ce/qe Vs Ce is linear and the constants KRP and αRP are determined from the slope and intercept (Table 3 ). KRP value of 4.878 is found for PTPDISA (R2= 0.993) indicating heterogeneous adsorption. The  KRP value of 0.9115  for PTP4ClB suggesting homogeneous adsorption.

Table 3: Adsorption studies of HgCl2 on Polymeric composites

Isotherm type

Parameter

PTP4ClB

PTPDISA

Langmuir

KL

11.06

3.03

qm

0.884

0.549

R2

0.992

0.952

R

0.995

0.975

 

RL

0.016

0.053

Freundlich

N

0.789

1.972

kF (L/mg)

0.600

1.873

R2

0.927

0.966

R

0.962

0.982

Dubinin Radushkevich

qD (mg/g)

5.926

5.185

B

2.198

1.580

R2

0.907

0.938

R

0.952

0.968

Tempkin

BT (L/mg)

0.042

0.037

AT (KJ/mol)

0.025

0.023

R2

0.935

0.900

R

0.966

0.948

Redlich Peterson

KRP (L/mg)

0.911

4.878

αRP

28.11

92

R2

0.905

0.988

R

0.951

0.993

Effect of Variation of Temperature

In order to verify the  influence of  temperature variation  on the process of adsorption , the experiment was conducted  at the temperatures between 303-318 K. The distribution coefficients (Kd) are calculated22 using the equation (7).

Kd = qe/Ce…………………….. (7)

Where qe  – the amount of metal adsorbed at equilibrium and Ce – equilibrium concentration of metal ions in solution.

The standard free energy change (ΔG⁰) is calculated from Van’t Hoff equation (8)

ΔG⁰ = -RTln Kd ……………………… (8)

 Where R= universal gas constant (8.314 J mol-1K-1)

The slope and intercept values of the plot of lnKd Vs 1/T are used to determine the values of ΔH⁰ and ΔS⁰.

lnKd=-ΔH⁰/RT+ΔS⁰/R  ………………….. (9)

 Thermodynamic parameters23,24 such as standard free energy of adsorption (ΔG⁰), standard enthalpy of adsorption (ΔH⁰) and the standard entropy of adsorption (ΔS⁰) are very helpful in understanding the adsorbent- adsorbate system. The negative value of ΔG⁰ indicates the feasibility of adsorption process (Table 4). The exothermic nature of adsorption is understood from ΔH⁰ values. The positive value of ΔS⁰ for both the investigated polymers shows the spontaneity of the adsorption process19. It also shows the affinity of adsorbent towards adsorbate species.

Table 4: Thermodynamic parameters for the adsorption of HgCl2 on Polymeric composites

Name of the pani composite

1/T*10-3

ΔG (KJ/mole)

ΔH (KJ/mole)

ΔS (J/mole)

PTP4ClB

3.30

3.24

3.19

3.14

-3.030

-2.249

-1.660

-0.154

-21.44

6.881

PTPDISA

3.30

3.24

3.19

3.14

-2.767

-0.951

-0.580

-0.062

-25.68

8.091

 

Powder XRD Study

The XRD patterns show several sharp peaks (Fig. 2a) in the region of 10˚-60˚(2Ɵ) with a step size of 0.001⁰ . The average particle size (D) is calculated from Debye Scherrer’s formula (10).

D= 0.9λ/β cos θ  …………………………………….. (10)

Where  λ = wavelength of CuKa radiation (1.54Å), β= full width at half maximum of peaks25.  The Particle size  varies from 40-160 nm for the  composites. The sharp peaks in the region of 20-62˚ illustrate the crystalline nature of polymeric composite . (Figure 2a,b).

Figure 2a: Powder XRD spectrum-after adsorption of mercuric chloride on PTP4ClB

Figure 2a: Powder XRD spectrum-after adsorption of mercuric chloride on PTP4ClB

Click here to View Figure

Figure 2b: Powder XRD spectrum-after adsorption of mercuric chloride on PTPDISA

Figure 2b: Powder XRD spectrum-after adsorption of mercuric chloride on PTPDISA

Click here to View Figure

Sem Analysis

The difference in morphology is observed in SEM picture of Polymeric composites before and after adsorption of HgCl2 confirming the adsorption of metal ion (Figure. 2 a-d). The particles are of small spherical in nature before adsorption while after adsorption the particles are larger, rod shaped and non-uniform in their size distribution. The embedded molecules of HgCl2 on Pani backbone are clearly visible.

Figure 3a,b: SEM analysis-before and after adsorption of HgCl2 on PTP4ClB composite

Figure 3a,b: SEM analysis-before and after adsorption of HgCl2 on PTP4ClB composite

Click here to View Figure

Figure 3c,d: SEM analysis-before and after adsorption of HgCl2 on PTPDISA composite

Figure 3c,d: SEM analysis-before and after adsorption of HgCl2 on PTPDISA composite

Click here to View Figure

EDX Analysis

Energy dispersive X- ray technique is used to find out the elemental composition and chemical characterisation of samples. The EDX spectra of the chosen composites present sharp peaks at 2-3 KeV strongly supporting the adsorption of mercuric ions on pani matrix.(Fig.3a,b)

Figure 4: EDX spectra of polymers after adsorption a) PTP4ClB b) PTPDISA

Figure 4: EDX spectra of polymers after adsorption a) PTP4ClB b) PTPDISA

Click here to View Figure

Conclusion

Two schiff base (TP4ClB and TPDISA) doped polymer composites (PTP4ClB amd PTPDISA) were prepared and characterized by UV-Visible, FT-IR and proton NMR spectroscopic techniques. The adsorption behaviour of the adsorbents were understood from  Langmuir, Freundlich, Dubinin Radushkevich, Temkin and Redlich Peterson isotherm models. It is observed that adsorption of mercuric chloride on both the new polymeric compounds is a favorable process as the adsorbents are best fitted for all the isotherms studied. The thermodynamic parameters calculated in the present work further confirms the feasibility of the adsorption process. SEM micrograph, PXRD and EDX spectra recorded  after adsorption are the supporting tools to indicate the adsorption of mercuric ion on the chosen adsorbents.

Acknowledgement

The authors express their heartfelt thanks to the Management, Principal, Vice principal of Seethalakshmi Ramaswami College, Trichy for the facilities provided and the continuous encouragement to carry out this research work.

Conflict of Interest

The authors decided that there is no conflict of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

References

  1. Babu Rao, G.; Krishna Prasad, M.; Murthy, Ch. V. R.; Int.J.Chem.Sci., 2015, 13, 1893-1910.
  2. Nishiyama, Y.;  Hanafusa, T.; Yamashita, J.; Yamamoto, Y.;  Ono, T.; J.Radioanal Nucl. Chem., 2016, 307, 1279-1285.
    CrossRef
  3. Dalia, M.; Saad, Ewa. M.; Cukrowska; Appl. water Sci., 2013, 3, 527-534.
    CrossRef
  4. Saad, D.W;  Cukrowska, E. M.; Tutu, H.; Appl. Water Sci, 2013, 3,527-534.
    CrossRef
  5. Bayazeed, H.; Abdullah, ; Yousif, M. Salh.; Orient.J.Chem.,2010, 26, 763-773.
  6. Qin, Li.; Li Sun.; Ya Zhang.; Yan Qian.; Jianping Zhai. ; Desalination, 2011, 266, 188-194.
    CrossRef
  7. Iqbal, S. A.;  Sibi Jose.;  Ishaq Zaafrany; Orient.J.Chem, 2012,28, 613-618.
    CrossRef
  8. Padmavathy,  K. S.; Madhu, G.; Haseena, P. V.; Procedia Technology, 2016,24, 585-594.
    CrossRef
  9. Joseph, A.; Ramamurthy, P. C.; Subramanian, S.; J.Appl.Polymer Sci, 2012,123, 526-534.
    CrossRef
  10. Vivekanandan, J.; Ponnusamy, V.; Mahudeswaran, A.; Vijayanand, P. S.; Scholars research library, Archives of applied science research, 2011, 3,147-153.
  11. Dhivya, C.; Vandarkuzhali, S. A. A.; Santhi, R.; Radha, N.; Indian J. Appl.Res., 2013,6 , 62.
  12. Rajeswari, B.; Santhi, R.; Radha, N.; International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews, 2018, 5 , 25-30.
  13. Abu nasar.; Fouzia Mashkor.; Environmental science and pollution research, 2019, 26, 5333-5356.
    CrossRef
  14. Ayawei, N.; Godwin, J.; Wankasi, D.; Int.J.Chem.Sci, 2015,13, 1197-1217.
  15. Djebbar, M.; Djafri, F.; Bouchekara, M.; Djafri, A.; Appl Water sci, 2012, 2, 77-86.
    CrossRef
  16. Singh, V. K.; Soni, A.B.; Singh, R.K.; Int.J.Chem.Sci., 2016,14, 2116-2138.
  17. Nethaji, S.; Sivasamy, A.; Mandal, A. B.; Int. j. Envir.Sci.Technol., 2013, 10, 231-242.
    CrossRef
  18. Moftakhar, M. K.; Yaftian, M.R.; Ghorbanloo, M.; Int. J. Environ. Sci.Technol., 2016, 13, 1707-1722.
    CrossRef
  19. Jameer Ahammad, S.; Sumithra, S.; Subha, R.; International Journal of chemical scinces, 2017, 15 ,161-172.
  20. Nimibofo Ayawei.; Augustus Newton Ebelegi.; Donbebe wankasi.; Hindawi journal of chemistry,  2017, 1-17
    CrossRef
  21. Mustapha, S.; Shuaib, D.T.;  Nasirudeen, M.B.; Applied water science,2019 ,9,142.
    CrossRef
  22. Renu ,  Madhu Agarwar,  Singh, K.;  Journal of water reuse and desalination, 2017.
    CrossRef
  23. Ayawei, N.;  Ekubo, A.T.;  Wankasi, D.; Dikio, E.D.; Orient.J.Chem ,2015, 31,1307-1318.
    CrossRef
  24. Reza Amini.; Nizomov, Z.; Razazi, M.; Ganiev, I.N.; Obidov, Z.R.; Orient.J.Chem, 2012, 28, 841-846.
    CrossRef
  25. Madavan, R.;  Murugesan, M.; Manikavasakam,  K.;  Sathish, R.; Manikandan, R.;  Savariraj Sagayam, C.;  Brindha, P.; International journal of pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences, 2012, 4, 163-166.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.