A Critical Comparative Study of Indoor Air Pollution from Household Cooking Fuels and its Effect on Health

This paper throws light on household cooking related exposures and level of indoor air pollutants (particulate matter and gaseous pollutants CO, CO2, SO2, NO, NO2) in different exposure area from the different types of cooking fuels used. Still the prevalence of biomass fuels exists in Indian households, combustion of which releases higher levels of solid and gaseous pollutants during the cooking hours. The indoor air pollutants (SPM, CO, CO2, SO2, NO, NO2) were measured with handy samplers with different types of cooking fuels (biomass and LPG). For this purpose 50 randomly selected sampled of the indoor air quality were monitored. The results suggests that average concentration of PM10 (394.07 ìg/m 3) and gaseous pollutants (CO-3.15 ppm, CO2492.63 ppm, SO20.56 ppm, NO-0.58 ppm, NO2-0.52 ppm) were highest during cooking hours with biofuels cooking places. Thus, not only the women who are involved in cooking suffer from the various ill effects, but also other family members who are inside the house during cooking hours also face exposures. The recorded SPM (114.73 ìg/m3 for PM10) and gaseous pollutants (CO-1.34 ppm, CO2-379.83 ppm, SO2-0.52 ppm, NO-0.54 ppm, NO2-0.52 ppm) in LPG using households were lower as compared to biomass fuel using households. Due to the LPG efficiency the time involved in cooking is also low leading to less exposure to the pollutants released.


INTRODUCTION
Atmospheric pollution is related with contagion of air or imbalance in the composition of air, while 'indoor air pollution can be demarcated as the sum of attributes of indoor atmosphere that affects a person's health and well-being'.In most of the developed country the important pollutants are volatile organic compounds, radon, heavy metals, asbestos, mites, pesticides, animal dander, moulds and tobacco smoke.However, as we focus on the developing countries, we will be finding that the most important indoor pollutants are the burning products of unrefined solid biomass fuelswhich is being regularly being used by the poor urban and rural folk people for heating and cooking.One of the major causes of the indoor air pollution is burning of cooking fuel (such as LPG, animal dung, wood, kerosene, agricultural residues, coal, etc.) 1 .Even today one half of the world's population, 95 percent in poor countries and more than 90 percent households of India are still using the tradional way of fuel and as well as conventional fuels though including biomass fuels 2 .Biomass fuel, refers to a vegetation or animal based material deliberately burned by humans and wood is the most common biofuel, but use of dung and harvest residues is also used frequently 3 .
It has been estimated that 50 times more noxious pollutants is released by unprocessed solid fuels than gas 4 .The efficiency Traditional fuels are characterized by low combustion efficiency that lead to huge emission of suspended particles and poisonous gases.The stoves or chulhas (u shaped open stoves made of bricks and mud) used for cooking purpose are not energy efficient in which the fuels are not completely burned.The incomplete combustion of fuels releases many a dozon of complex toxic pollutants hazardous to health.Among these health damaging pollutants, toxic and irritant gases, the most important include PM, CO, NO 2 , SO 2 , HCHO and carcinogens for example benzo (0) pyrene and benzene 5 .The exposure to indoor smoke is particularly high among women and children because women spend responsible for family cooking and children below the age of five there most of the time with their mothers while they are engaged in cooking 6 .Women generally begin regular cooking or start assisting in cooking around the age of 12 to 15 which leads to longer period of exposure to pollutants.Women spend between 3 to 7 hours per day near the stove for cooking food 7 .Due to customary involvement in the cooking women's exposure is very much higher than men's and many times the young ones are carried on mother's backs or on laps while cooking and thus they spend many hours breathing toxic pollutants.
Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) is one of the complex issues than any of the other environmental issues.Researchers indicate the presence of more than 900 contaminants in indoor air depending on different operational activities.The most important identified indoor air pollutants are polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), sulphur dioxide (SO 2 ), carbon monoxide (CO), carbon dioxide (CO 2 ), oxides of nitrogen (NO, NO 2 ), particulate matter etc 8 .The sources of these pollutants are innumerable, such as, building materials used, carpets, furniture, smoking indoors, cooking fuels used, heating, cleaning etc., but the most important identified source by WHO is cooking with solid fuels.
Despite adverse health effects of indoor air pollution, this complex problem is not highlighted and discussed.Most sources of air pollutants normally monitored outdoors as according to the National Air Quality standard and very little is known about air pollution indoors 9 .Moreover, from combustion of traditional fuels the toxic pollutants released has been implicated and are risk for most respiratory diseases (such as tuberculosis, asthma, acute respiratory infections, chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases, etc.), cancers, adverse pregnancy outcomes, eye problems, accidental problems, etc., particularly among women who are usually regarded as responsible for household work management and cooking in Indian cultural values.The city is situated 1400 km from New Delhi and a little less than 300 km north-west of Kolkata on the (NH-33) and Eastern Railway.The chief rivers are the swarnrekha and Kharkai.Tata Nagar is located in the south east region of Jharkhand.The city is located in the Chhota Nagpur plateau and covers an area of 3533 km 2 .Sampling site is close to state highway Jamshedpur Kandra road, Godowns of Food Corporation of India, hotels, bakeries and Adityapur railway station also exist in the vicinity of the sampling area.Tata Nagar one of the major industrial centres also known as steel gaint producer of Eastern India.It houses companies like Tata Steel, TCE, Lafarge, Tata Motors, BOC Gases, Tata Power, Cement, Telcon, Praxair, TCS, Timken, TRF, Tinplate and many more.It homes to one of the largest industrial zones of India known as Adityapur which houses more than 1,200 small and medium scale industries and has an SEZ named AIDA in the Adityapur.The details of sampling sites for the collection of PM 10 are shown in fig 1

For indoor PM 10
Monitoring was carried out chulla at open space, with different usages of cooking fuel to diagnose the indoor air quality (IAQ) and to find out the concentration of suspended PM 10 .This monitoring was carried out with the help of the handy sampler in the month of May, 2015.For the purpose of sampling, households kitchen using biomass fuels and LPG in chulhas were selected in open space.The pollutant monitoring of SPM was performed 1/2 hour before cooking and two and half hour during cooking.The concentration of suspended particulate matter was averaged over and was recorded at 5 minute intervals.For the purpose of monitoring of released and suspended PM 10 , a portable sampler "GRIMM Dust Monitor Series 1.109" (Grimm Aerosol technic; Doff strabe 9; 83404 Airing Germany) was used.The operational characteristics of GRIMM is shown in table 1

For gaseous pollutants
Monitoring was carried out to measure the concentration of indoor gaseous pollutants with special emphasis on the measurement of emissions from the energy used for cooking.The levels of concentration of CO 2 , CO, SO 2 , oxides of NO & NO 2 were monitored.This monitoring was carried out with the help of the handy sampler in summer May, 2015.The levels of pollutants released through the combustion of different fuels were assessed from 6.30 am to 6.30 pm for the houses using biomass fuels/chulla & LPG/gas stoves.For the monitoring of indoor gaseous pollutants (CO 2 , CO, SO 2 , NO, NO 2 ), handy samplers were used having separate sensors for sensing the concentration of each type of pollutant.The indoor gaseous pollutants like CO, SO 2 , NO, NO 2 were measured by portable YES-205 multigas monitor (Young Environmental System 205 Inc.Vantage way, Delta, Canada).The concentration of CO 2 was measured by a portable YES-206 Falcon Indoor Air Quality monitor (Young Environmental

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The United States Environmental Protection Agency 2006, [10] (EPA) standard for an acceptable annual 24-hour average of PM 10 is 150 µg/m 3 , and they state that this level of pollutants should not be exceeded more than once per year.

PM 10 pollutant Biomass as cooking fuel
Fig 2 shows the average daily PM 10 concentration of 248.97 g/m 3 of which the peak value recorded was 384.30 µg/m 3 while the minimum was 123.30 µg/m 3 around cooking, place in the open just before cooking hour.The outdoor cooking with biomass cooking fuel exhibited much higher concentration of PM 10 and the average daily concentration was found to be 430.37 µg/m 3 of which the highest value recorded was 685.30 µg/m 3 while the minimum concentration recorded was 264.10.µg/ m 3 .The level of concentration of PM was found much higher in open space, it was attributed to outdoor atmospheric effect and as the exposed area is large, the PM gets diffused in the atmosphere and cause health hazard.

LPG as cooking fuel
Fig 2 shows the average daily concentration of 93.70 µg/m 3 in open space, of which the maximum recorded concentration was 112.10 µg/m 3 while the minimum recorded concentration was 79.50 µg/ m 3 just before the cooking hours.The cooking hour average concentration of PM 10 recorded was 119.99 µg/m 3 of which the maximum recorded value was 248.10 µg/m 3 while the minimum recorded value was 64.80 µg/m 3 .It was observed that the concentration of PM 10 was much higher during cooking hours compared to the concentration level before cooking hour.

Gaseous pollutants Biomass as cooking fuel
Fig. 3(a, b, c, d & e) is showing the concentration of gaseous pollutants (CO, CO 2 , SO 2 , Fig. 3. (a, b, c, d &   The highest concentrations were observed at the time of ignition of fire in chulhas when the fire in chulhas was blown with mouth or blow pipe for more heat.At this time the concentration of gaseous pollutants was higher due to emitted smoke and when the smoke dissipated the concentration of all these pollutants declined.The average daily concentrations of CO, CO 2 , SO 2 , NO, NO 2 were recorded to be 1.34 ppm, 379.83 ppm, 0.52 ppm, 0.54 ppm and 0.52 ppm respectively.During the monitoring hours, the maximum recorded concentrations of gaseous pollutants were, 1.70 ppm, 556.00 ppm, 0.06 ppm, 0.07 ppm, 0.04 ppm and the minimum recorded values were, 0.20 ppm, 234.00 ppm, 0.00 ppm, 0.01 ppm, 0.00 ppm of CO, CO 2 , SO 2 , NO, NO 2 respectively.The highest concentrations were during the whole day monitoring were observed in morning, day time and in the evening i.e., during the cooking hours while in noncooking hours the lower concentration of pollutant were recorded.

Linkages of respiratory disease symptoms with fuel use
The linkages between self-reported respiratory disease symptoms includes cough, phlegm, breathlessness, wheezing, blood in sputum and any other symptoms like fever, sore throat, running nose etc.On the basis of self-reported symptoms the occurrence of respiratory diseases was examined in the households using different type of fuels (BIOMASS & LPG) is in Table 4.
The results suggest that the average concentration of indoor air pollutants was highest during cooking hours with biofuels.The study reveals that the concentration of indoor pollutants, especially PM, CO 2 , CO, SO 2 , NO, NO 2 is maximum when cooking is done using biomass in chulhas.The exposure to chief cook is very high in when cooking is done using biomass.Another important finding is that the household members who are inside the house during the cooking hours also face the effects of high exposures.This is because most of the households using biomass burn them in open fires/ chulhas that release most of the smoke into the house.The resulting indoor air pollution is a major threat to health, particularly for women and young children who may spend many hours close to the fire.Much higher levels of pollutants are released during cooking hours.As per EPA (environmental protection agencies), the particulate of 10 µm or less than that in size easily passes through the nose, throat and enter the lungs posing health risks.The increase in mortality rate on a global scale from 4.0% to 8.0% of premature deaths are due to exposure to high levels particulate matter in the ambient and indoor environment 11 which is tabled in table 5.

Fig 3 (
a, b, c, d & e) is showing the concentration of common gaseous pollutants (CO, CO 2 , SO 2 , NO, NO 2 ) in the kitchen during the working hours (including cooking hours) inside the house.

Table 1 : Operational characteristics of portable GRIMM dust monitor Measuring principle 90 0 light scattering
Mass Mass concentration with 31 size channels from 0.25->32 µm in µg/m 2 Particle Particle concentration in 31 measuring channels applied to the volume of one litre sample air